The Irascible Agatha Raisin

Agatha Raisin and the Potted Gardener
Agatha Raisin Mystery series #3

By M C Beaton

I read the first book in the Agatha Raisin Mystery series, Agatha Raisin and the Quiche of Death, and one other short story tacked onto that one. Now I’ve finished the third book in the series and have had my fill. Actually, though I hate to quit before the end of any book, I was ready to toss this one several times before I discovered whodunit.

The setting in interesting; the plotting, pacing and writing are excellent, but the main character is so disagreeable. Back in London she was a hard-nosed — and pretty much friendless — business owner and she carries this personality into her retirement years. She may want to make friends in her new home town and does mean well — at times. Overall, though, she’s self-centered and defensive. I was hoping to see Agatha mellow in this peaceful Cotswold village as the series progresses. She doesn’t.

Pugnacious and mulish are the adjectives the author often uses to describe Mrs Raisin. Belligerent and snarky would also fit. She lies constantly, swears, staggers home tipsy from the village pub, insults almost everyone, and has a real temper. In one story she invites the neighbours for a Christmas dinner, but bashes one lustful old guest over the head with a Christmas pudding.

Always competitive, she cheats in village contests. In The Quiche of Death she’s newly arrived and wants the acceptance of the villagers. She sees her chance when she discovers there’s to be a village baking contest. Culinarily-challenged herself, she buys a quiche from a great little bakery in London and submits it as her own creation. Unfortunately someone adds a bit of poison and serves it to the judge. So the truth must be confessed.

In this third book she wants to impress certain gardeners and win the local flower show, but she’s hopeless at growing things. Supposedly she’s learned her lesson with the quiche, but weakens and buys a nursery-grown rose to enter as her own. Forgetting to take off the tag. Again her deception is exposed, but village folks are amazingly tolerant.

One big plus for Agatha is that she’s made friends with Mrs Bloxby, the curate’s wife, who is a saint for sure. Sanguine, welcoming, accepting, charitable, always thinking the best, she saves and soothes Agatha’s pride several times in this story. Agatha is also friends with her bachelor neighbour James, a retired army colonel — on whom she has a serious crush as this story starts. (I gather they work together in several stories to figure out whodunit.) However, Agatha insults him, too, petulantly calling him a male chauvinist pig when he scolds her for throwing a lit cigarette into the tinder-dry grass.

Like all amateur sleuths in all cozy mystery stories, she’s nosy. When the local CID inspector Bill Wong, who has taken a liking to Agatha, tells her to stay out of the investigation, she slips on her halo and nods a meek “Yes.” As soon as he’s out of sight, she and James are off hunting for evidence and interviewing suspects. In this book she’s trying to find out why a lovely divorcee, Mary Fortune, a newcomer and enthusiastic gardener, has met a sad end in her conservatory.

Because this is fiction, the writer is able to say that in spite of Agatha’s abrasive character she’s well liked by the villagers. Some characters testify that “Mrs Raisin has many good qualities.” In real life this would be highly unlikely. I know a woman much like this: not as insolent or combative as Agatha but just as self-centered and flexible with the truth. Her friendships and relationships are all short-lived.

I have some sympathy for Agatha Raisin because she is so lacking in interpersonal skills, but find her lack of conscience hard to take. Since the villagers of Carsely are stuck with her it’s a good thing they like her. And since it’s such a popular series — as I gather from the reviews — a lot of readers are willing to tolerate her faults, too.

Ragtag Daily Prompt word: Evidence
Word of the Day Challenge: Sanguine

14 thoughts on “The Irascible Agatha Raisin

    1. I tried to be honest, but am biased, I’ll admit. 🙂
      I gather this is already a TV series and wonder if she’s any more pleasant in the role, or just as pugnacious?

      I’ve heard people say, “This is how I really am and I’m not going to be a phony by pretending to be nice. People can take me just the way I am.” It takes some folks years to learn that treating people with kindness does help keep friendships warm and spouses loving. 🙂

      Liked by 1 person

  1. We saw about 3 episodes of Agatha Raisin, that aired on PBS or something. She seemed insecure and a little sad in the series, but had a few tolerant and supportive friends. She had a need to “fit in”, and tried too hard, and in the wrong way, however, I quite liked the character. One of the things I remember is how she wore high heels all the time, even when she shouldn’t have. At least she always solved the crime!

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Thanks for your comment. In some ways her character is likeable. Definitely insecure and trying too hard, in the wrong way. She doesn’t wear heels in the book; for the most part she scorns high heels and clothes that are uncomfortable.

      Did she lie as much in the series? In the book she’s constantly lying and denying, especially to cover her mistakes. In this book she stubbornly sets the plants outside in spite of being warned about the predicted frost. Then when they freeze she lies to the neighbour when he point-blank asks her, “Did you set them out?” Or when she says, “I dropped it,” after she furiously smashes the Christmas pudding down on the old geezer’s head.

      Liked by 1 person

      1. I’m glad, too. we’re so into anti-heroes these days. I read a book about a cop who lost his job for punching out a co-worker, and in the story he frequently fantasized–in quite the detail–about bashing people who annoyed him. He had taken anger management courses so he didn’t actually do it, but still… And in the end it was another cop who did the murders.

        Liked by 1 person

I'd like to hear your thoughts on this. Please leave a comment.

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.